Overall Steamer vs. NFBC Ranks

Written by

Published on March 20, 2017

I re-ranked and valued the hitters and pitchers more appropriately in my last two posts by accounting for both catcher and closer scarcity, respectively. Here I put the two lists together and show the difference in dollars, rather than ADP spots.

The rankings are sorted in order of Steamer's dollar values (as translated by my formula):

Steamer Rk	Player	Steamer $	NFBC ADP	NFBC $	$ Diff
1	Clayton Kershaw	43.32	3	41.38	1.94
2	Mike Trout	42.46	1	44.38	-1.92
3	Mookie Betts	38.73	2	43.75	-5.02
4	Manny Machado	35.20	8	39.13	-3.93
5	Jose Altuve	33.59	4	41.13	-7.54
6	Miguel Cabrera	33.59	14	33.63	-0.04
7	Nolan Arenado	33.54	6	39.50	-5.96
8	Bryce Harper	31.68	9	36.88	-5.20
9	Trea Turner	31.65	10	35.88	-4.23
10	Max Scherzer	31.31	12	35.13	-3.82
11	Anthony Rizzo	30.01	13	34.25	-4.24
12	Kris Bryant	29.86	5	40.25	-10.39
13	Paul Goldschmidt	28.80	7	39.25	-10.45
14	Noah Syndergaard	27.78	18	31.88	-4.10
15	Josh Donaldson	27.64	11	35.38	-7.74
16	Madison Bumgarner	26.88	15	33.13	-6.25
17	Charlie Blackmon	26.53	17	32.25	-5.72
18	Kenley Jansen	26.46	45	22.53	3.93
19	Chris Sale	25.72	21	30.13	-4.41
20	Aroldis Chapman	25.54	44	22.80	2.74
21	Corey Kluber	24.66	24	29.05	-4.39
22	Carlos Gonzalez	24.14	64	17.89	6.25
23	Carlos Correa	24.07	16	32.63	-8.56
24	Rougned Odor	23.74	40	23.93	-0.19
25	Nelson Cruz	23.17	39	24.22	-1.05
26	Robinson Cano	22.94	30	27.01	-4.07
27	Joey Votto	22.28	22	29.76	-7.48
28	Freddie Freeman	22.01	26	28.35	-6.34
29	Corey Seager	21.97	19	30.38	-8.41
30	Giancarlo Stanton	21.79	38	24.52	-2.73
31	Jose Abreu	21.75	62	18.33	3.42
32	Xander Bogaerts	21.70	27	28.01	-6.31
33	Stephen Strasburg	21.65	51	20.95	0.70
34	Jon Lester	21.62	35	25.43	-3.81
35	Jonathan Villar	21.48	20	30.38	-8.90
36	Andrew Miller	21.27	115	9.65	11.62
37	Francisco Lindor	20.97	28	27.68	-6.71
38	Eric Thames	20.96	178	4.50	16.46
39	Johnny Cueto	20.89	42	23.36	-2.47
40	Carlos Carrasco	20.88	60	18.78	2.10
41	George Springer	20.84	32	26.37	-5.53
42	Starling Marte	20.84	23	29.40	-8.56
43	Andrew McCutchen	20.62	69	16.84	3.78
44	Chris Archer	20.41	50	21.20	-0.79
45	Justin Verlander	20.03	43	23.08	-3.05
46	Yu Darvish	19.96	31	26.69	-6.73
47	Justin Upton	19.82	83	14.22	5.60
48	Christian Yelich	19.82	57	19.48	0.34
49	Adam Jones	19.56	117	9.42	10.14
50	Daniel Murphy	19.23	37	24.82	-5.59
51	Carlos Santana	19.02	120	9.08	9.94
52	Edwin Diaz	18.69	78	15.10	3.59
53	Ryan Braun	18.63	46	22.25	-3.62
54	Adrian Beltre	18.48	84	14.04	4.44
55	J.D. Martinez	18.40	52	20.69	-2.29
56	Eric Hosmer	18.34	106	10.76	7.58
57	Gary Sanchez	18.30	48	21.72	-3.42
58	Brian Dozier	18.30	36	25.12	-6.82
59	Ian Desmond	18.16	56	19.72	-1.56
60	Wade Davis	18.04	85	13.88	4.16
61	Jake Arrieta	17.82	33	26.05	-8.23
62	Chris Davis	17.74	81	14.56	3.18
63	Edwin Encarnacion	17.54	25	28.70	-11.16
64	DJ LeMahieu	17.44	86	13.71	3.73
65	Mark Trumbo	17.42	72	16.24	1.18
66	Yoenis Cespedes	17.39	58	19.24	-1.85
67	Khris Davis	17.32	99	11.71	5.61
68	Evan Longoria	17.01	104	11.02	5.99
69	Wil Myers	16.72	55	19.96	-3.24
70	Maikel Franco	16.70	121	8.97	7.73
71	Buster Posey	16.66	41	23.64	-6.98
72	Hanley Ramirez	16.52	79	14.92	1.60
73	A.J. Pollock	16.51	34	25.74	-9.23
74	Kyle Seager	16.40	68	17.05	-0.65
75	Gregory Polanco	16.34	63	18.11	-1.77
76	Zach Britton	16.31	59	19.01	-2.70
77	Kyle Schwarber	16.07	77	15.29	0.78
78	Todd Frazier	16.02	75	15.66	0.36
79	Albert Pujols	15.93	136	7.48	8.45
80	Craig Kimbrel	15.40	74	15.85	-0.45
81	Trevor Story	15.20	29	27.34	-12.14
82	Adam Eaton	15.12	126	8.44	6.68
83	Anthony Rendon	15.08	90	13.06	2.02
84	Jean Segura	14.94	54	20.20	-5.26
85	Mark Melancon	14.88	70	16.64	-1.76
86	Shawn Kelley	14.87	211	3.02	11.85
87	Dallas Keuchel	14.86	145	6.71	8.15
88	David Price	14.82	61	18.56	-3.74
89	Matt Kemp	14.67	92	12.75	1.92
90	Lance McCullers	14.53	162	5.46	9.07
91	Victor Martinez	14.28	229	2.43	11.85
92	Dee Gordon	14.25	47	21.99	-7.74
93	Ian Kinsler	14.19	76	15.47	-1.28
94	Jacob deGrom	14.11	66	17.47	-3.36
95	Jose Bautista	13.87	112	10.00	3.87
96	Matt Carpenter	13.62	71	16.44	-2.82
97	Kendrys Morales	13.55	160	5.59	7.96
98	Ken Giles	13.48	88	13.38	0.10
99	Justin Turner	13.45	128	8.24	5.21
100	Mike Moustakas	13.35	206	3.20	10.15
101	Alex Bregman	13.32	91	12.90	0.42
102	Tommy Joseph	13.18	214	2.91	10.27
103	Rich Hill	13.16	125	8.55	4.61
104	Masahiro Tanaka	13.15	87	13.54	-0.39
105	Kole Calhoun	13.09	186	4.08	9.01
106	Matt Shoemaker	13.05	222	2.64	10.41
107	Dustin Pedroia	13.02	137	7.39	5.63
108	Jose Ramirez	12.87	93	12.59	0.28
109	Kyle Hendricks	12.82	65	17.68	-4.86
110	Jonathan Lucroy	12.75	53	20.44	-7.69
111	Seung Hwan Oh	12.74	73	16.05	-3.31
112	Danny Salazar	12.62	124	8.65	3.97
113	Gerrit Cole	12.62	110	10.25	2.37
114	Michael Pineda	12.54	203	3.32	9.22
115	Carlos Martinez	12.43	67	17.26	-4.83
116	Jose Quintana	12.28	105	10.89	1.39
117	James Paxton	12.24	166	5.20	7.04
118	Billy Hamilton	12.10	49	21.46	-9.36
119	Jason Kipnis	12.10	100	11.57	0.53
120	Jameson Taillon	12.09	151	6.24	5.85
121	Odubel Herrera	12.05	119	9.19	2.86
122	Melky Cabrera	11.97	261	1.65	10.32
123	Robbie Ray	11.95	213	2.94	9.01
124	Danny Duffy	11.93	97	12.00	-0.07
125	Stephen Piscotty	11.84	130	8.04	3.80
126	Aledmys Diaz	11.61	150	6.31	5.30
127	Miguel Sano	11.59	118	9.30	2.29
128	Jeff Samardzija	11.41	198	3.53	7.88
129	Salvador Perez	11.26	133	7.76	3.50
130	Kevin Kiermaier	11.02	179	4.44	6.58
131	Rick Porcello	10.89	111	10.13	0.76
132	Cole Hamels	10.88	82	14.39	-3.51
133	Cam Bedrosian	10.84	210	3.05	7.79
134	Marcell Ozuna	10.77	181	4.34	6.43
135	Steven Matz	10.70	157	5.80	4.90
136	Kelvin Herrera	10.57	94	12.44	-1.87
137	Zack Greinke	10.51	96	12.14	-1.63
138	Tim Anderson	10.40	156	5.87	4.53
139	Roberto Osuna	10.13	80	14.74	-4.61
140	Lorenzo Cain	10.12	131	7.95	2.17
141	Jeurys Familia	10.06	114	9.77	0.29
142	Jonathan Schoop	10.00	165	5.26	4.74
143	Dellin Betances	9.94	177	4.55	5.39
144	Brad Miller	9.87	161	5.53	4.34
145	Aaron Nola	9.84	200	3.45	6.39
146	Raisel Iglesias	9.46	173	4.78	4.68
147	Matt Moore	9.43	176	4.61	4.82
148	Yasiel Puig	9.40	220	2.70	6.70
149	Carlos Gomez	9.37	152	6.16	3.21
150	Evan Gattis	9.37	107	10.63	-1.26
151	Stephen Vogt	9.27	204	3.28	5.99
152	Adrian Gonzalez	9.00	172	4.84	4.16
153	John Lackey	8.95	159	5.66	3.29
154	Yadier Molina	8.91	190	3.89	5.02
155	Shin-Soo Choo	8.89	328	0.00	8.89
156	Yasmani Grandal	8.80	141	7.04	1.76
157	Willson Contreras	8.77	89	13.22	-4.45
158	Kenta Maeda	8.76	95	12.29	-3.53
159	Jake Lamb	8.54	144	6.79	1.75
160	Matt Holliday	8.51	262	1.63	6.88
161	Nomar Mazara	8.45	201	3.40	5.05
162	Andrew Benintendi	8.45	129	8.14	0.31
163	Joc Pederson	8.36	195	3.66	4.70
164	Marcus Semien	8.27	207	3.17	5.10
165	Ryon Healy	8.26	197	3.57	4.69
166	Rajai Davis	8.26	194	3.71	4.55
167	Brandon Belt	8.15	169	5.02	3.13
168	J.T. Realmuto	8.04	113	9.88	-1.84
169	Carlos Beltran	7.92	216	2.84	5.08
170	Felix Hernandez	7.68	135	7.57	0.11
171	Ender Inciarte	7.67	196	3.62	4.05
172	Drew Smyly	7.58	215	2.87	4.71
173	Greg Bird	7.47	241	2.10	5.37
174	Logan Forsythe	7.29	219	2.74	4.55
175	Kevin Gausman	7.14	146	6.63	0.51
176	Jon Gray	6.95	180	4.39	2.56
177	Vince Velasquez	6.94	182	4.29	2.65
178	Max Kepler	6.94	234	2.28	4.66
179	Garrett Richards	6.89	238	2.17	4.72
180	Adam Duvall	6.87	155	5.94	0.93
181	Mike Napoli	6.83	217	2.80	4.03
182	Marcus Stroman	6.78	154	6.02	0.76
183	Matt Harvey	6.67	148	6.47	0.20
184	Jackie Bradley	6.66	143	6.87	-0.21
185	David Robertson	6.64	123	8.76	-2.12
186	David Peralta	6.60	265	1.57	5.03
187	Domingo Santana	6.60	254	1.79	4.81
188	Josh Reddick	6.55	299	0.00	6.55
189	Gio Gonzalez	6.50	291	0.00	6.50
190	Brian McCann	6.40	168	5.08	1.32
191	Julio Teheran	6.36	108	10.50	-4.14
192	Elvis Andrus	6.29	153	6.09	0.20
193	Cody Allen	6.25	101	11.43	-5.18
194	Collin McHugh	6.19	284	0.00	6.19
195	Alex Colome	6.19	98	11.85	-5.66
196	Dexter Fowler	6.15	187	4.03	2.12
197	Russell Martin	6.09	167	5.14	0.95
198	Randal Grichuk	5.92	212	2.98	2.94
199	Curtis Granderson	5.80	279	0.00	5.80
200	Michael Fulmer	5.63	139	7.21	-1.58
201	Ben Zobrist	5.48	175	4.66	0.82
202	Tony Watson	5.48	147	6.55	-1.07
203	Neil Walker	5.28	247	1.95	3.33
204	Didi Gregorius	5.25	253	1.81	3.44
205	Nick Castellanos	5.21	202	3.36	1.85
206	Troy Tulowitzki	5.10	158	5.73	-0.63
207	Brett Gardner	5.06	285	0.00	5.06
208	Corey Dickerson	5.03	290	0.00	5.03
209	Martin Prado	5.01	340	0.00	5.01
210	Starlin Castro	4.94	236	2.23	2.71
211	David Dahl	4.85	103	11.16	-6.31
212	Yasmany Tomas	4.73	149	6.39	-1.66
213	Josh Bell	4.71	293	0.00	4.71
214	Jacoby Ellsbury	4.71	250	1.88	2.83
215	Jason Heyward	4.69	256	1.75	2.94
216	Kevin Pillar	4.66	304	0.00	4.66
217	Adam Wainwright	4.66	225	2.55	2.11
218	Jake Odorizzi	4.50	183	4.23	0.27
219	Denard Span	4.47	356	0.00	4.47
220	Carlos Rodon	4.36	191	3.84	0.52
221	Cesar Hernandez	4.36	283	0.00	4.36
222	Justin Bour	4.26	302	0.00	4.26
223	Jung Ho Kang	4.23	258	1.71	2.52
224	Dansby Swanson	4.15	185	4.13	0.02
225	Addison Russell	4.14	134	7.66	-3.52
226	Wilson Ramos	4.12	269	1.49	2.63
227	Aaron Sanchez	4.12	102	11.29	-7.17
228	Blake Snell	4.10	231	2.37	1.73
229	Brandon Moss	4.09	315	0.00	4.09
230	Hisashi Iwakuma	4.07	271	1.46	2.61
231	Matt Wieters	4.07	189	3.94	0.13
232	Welington Castillo	4.05	174	4.72	-0.67
233	Joe Mauer	3.93	409	0.00	3.93
234	Jose Peraza	3.93	109	10.38	-6.45
235	Brandon Maurer	3.77	233	2.31	1.46
236	Austin Hedges	3.73	297	0.00	3.73
237	Devon Travis	3.68	208	3.13	0.55
238	Eugenio Suarez	3.57	264	1.59	1.98
239	Joe Ross	3.47	239	2.15	1.32
240	Hunter Renfroe	3.46	228	2.45	1.01
241	J.A. Happ	3.45	193	3.75	-0.30
242	Byron Buxton	3.40	140	7.13	-3.73
243	Javier Baez	3.31	122	8.86	-5.55
244	Mike Zunino	3.28	278	0.00	3.28
245	Ian Kennedy	3.25	252	1.84	1.41
246	Drew Pomeranz	3.24	218	2.77	0.47
247	Lance Lynn	3.23	282	0.00	3.23
248	Hunter Pence	3.11	209	3.09	0.02
249	Keon Broxton	3.09	170	4.96	-1.87
250	Nick Markakis	2.94	374	0.00	2.94
251	Eduardo Nunez	2.71	116	9.53	-6.82
252	Ivan Nova	2.51	260	1.67	0.84
253	Francisco Cervelli	2.45	310	0.00	2.45
254	Travis Jankowski	2.43	287	0.00	2.43
255	Yan Gomes	2.25	309	0.00	2.25
256	Julio Urias	2.16	164	5.33	-3.17
257	Neftali Feliz	2.13	255	1.77	0.36
258	Michael Brantley	1.88	224	2.58	-0.70
259	Alcides Escobar	1.80	327	0.00	1.80
260	Sam Dyson	1.71	142	6.96	-5.25
261	Travis d'Arnaud	1.67	274	1.41	0.26
262	Steve Pearce	1.61	405	0.00	1.61
263	Sean Manaea	1.53	171	4.90	-3.37
264	Jharel Cotton	1.44	237	2.20	-0.76
265	Seth Smith	1.25	426	0.00	1.25
266	Josh Harrison	1.19	273	1.42	-0.23
267	Jason Castro	1.18	379	0.00	1.18
268	Brandon Crawford	1.13	248	1.93	-0.80
269	Taijuan Walker	1.12	227	2.48	-1.36
270	Jerad Eickhoff	1.10	205	3.24	-2.14
271	Tanner Roark	1.08	138	7.30	-6.22
272	A.J. Ramos	1.05	127	8.34	-7.29
273	Francisco Liriano	1.01	305	0.00	1.01
274	Fernando Rodney	1.00	257	1.73	-0.73
275	Cameron Rupp	0.97	243	2.05	-1.08
276	Matt Duffy	0.97	337	0.00	0.97
277	Alex Gordon	0.84	326	0.00	0.84
278	Jeremy Hellickson	0.81	311	0.00	0.81
279	Yuli Gurriel	0.71	272	1.44	-0.73
280	Jedd Gyorko	0.66	251	1.86	-1.20
281	Joe Panik	0.60	317	0.00	0.60
282	Jay Bruce	0.50	199	3.49	-2.99
283	Yangervis Solarte	0.50	289	0.00	0.50
284	Zach Davies	0.47	298	0.00	0.47
285	Manuel Margot	0.46	249	1.90	-1.44
286	Yunel Escobar	0.42	455	0.00	0.42
287	James McCann	0.41	321	0.00	0.41
288	Asdrubal Cabrera	0.23	268	1.51	-1.28
289	Lucas Duda	0.10	349	0.00	0.10
290	Francisco Rodriguez	0.09	132	7.85	-7.76
291	Tyler Glasnow	0.06	281	0.00	0.06
292	Sonny Gray	0.03	221	2.67	-2.64
293	Adam Ottavino	0.00	163	5.39	-5.39
294	Hector Neris	0.00	240	2.12	-2.12
295	Jim Johnson	0.00	192	3.80	-3.80
296	Ryan Madson	0.00	232	2.34	-2.34
297	Addison Reed	0.00	259	1.69	-1.69
298	Nate Jones	0.00	263	1.61	-1.61
299	Brandon Kintzler	0.00	266	1.55	-1.55
300	Greg Holland	0.00	308	0.00	0.00
301	Mike Foltynewicz	-0.20	313	0.00	-0.20
302	Ervin Santana	-0.22	329	0.00	-0.22
303	Jayson Werth	-0.34	373	0.00	-0.34
304	Tyler Flowers	-0.48	350	0.00	-0.48
305	Scott Schebler	-0.52	386	0.00	-0.52
306	Anthony DeSclafani	-0.60	244	2.02	-2.62
307	Howie Kendrick	-0.62	343	0.00	-0.62
308	Ryan Zimmerman	-0.76	404	0.00	-0.76
309	Jarrod Dyson	-1.05	223	2.61	-3.66
310	Alex Cobb	-1.07	300	0.00	-1.07
311	Jorge Polanco	-1.17	372	0.00	-1.17
312	Eduardo Rodriguez	-1.17	292	0.00	-1.17
313	Devin Mesoraco	-1.29	295	0.00	-1.29
314	Avisail Garcia	-1.41	416	0.00	-1.41
315	Trevor Plouffe	-1.44	435	0.00	-1.44
316	Mitch Haniger	-1.53	353	0.00	-1.53
317	C.J. Cron	-1.57	235	2.26	-3.83
318	Jordan Zimmermann	-1.63	320	0.00	-1.63
319	Michael Saunders	-1.73	363	0.00	-1.73
320	Steven Souza	-1.73	348	0.00	-1.73
321	Orlando Arcia	-1.85	270	1.48	-3.33
322	Jose Iglesias	-1.85	465	0.00	-1.85
323	Jett Bandy	-1.87	399	0.00	-1.87
324	Ryan Schimpf	-1.90	344	0.00	-1.90
325	Andrelton Simmons	-1.91	371	0.00	-1.91
326	Jason Hammel	-1.98	324	0.00	-1.98
327	Junior Guerra	-2.06	275	1.39	-3.45
328	Jorge Soler	-2.06	286	0.00	-2.06
329	Sandy Leon	-2.12	277	0.00	-2.12
330	Pablo Sandoval	-2.12	364	0.00	-2.12
331	Trevor Bauer	-2.20	314	0.00	-2.20
332	Chase Headley	-2.27	434	0.00	-2.27
333	Kolten Wong	-2.31	330	0.00	-2.31
334	Tom Murphy	-2.62	226	2.51	-5.13
335	Aaron Judge	-2.71	376	0.00	-2.71
336	Chris Carter	-2.73	276	1.37	-4.10
337	Hyun Soo Kim	-2.83	431	#N/A	#N/A
338	Chris Herrmann	-3.04	375	0.00	-3.04
339	Daniel Norris	-3.24	280	0.00	-3.24
340	Marco Estrada	-3.42	230	2.40	-5.82
341	Mitch Moreland	-3.44	338	0.00	-3.44
342	Dylan Bundy	-3.56	267	1.53	-5.09
343	Brandon Drury	-3.58	246	1.97	-5.55
344	Leonys Martin	-3.71	242	2.07	-5.78
345	Tyler Naquin	-3.79	318	0.00	-3.79
346	Kennys Vargas	-3.90	429	0.00	-3.90
347	Jhonny Peralta	-4.21	456	0.00	-4.21
348	Cameron Maybin	-4.56	296	0.00	-4.56
349	Jose Reyes	-4.78	294	0.00	-4.78
350	Jurickson Profar	-5.27	369	0.00	-5.27
351	Brandon Finnegan	-5.28	333	0.00	-5.28
352	Zack Cozart	-5.49	385	0.00	-5.49
353	Travis Shaw	-5.54	306	0.00	-5.54
354	Hernan Perez	-5.62	184	4.18	-9.80
355	Danny Valencia	-5.84	335	0.00	-5.84
356	Lonnie Chisenhall	-6.05	448	0.00	-6.05
357	Colby Rasmus	-6.21	479	0.00	-6.21
358	Brandon Phillips	-6.30	288	0.00	-6.30
359	Eddie Rosario	-6.74	408	0.00	-6.74
360	Adonis Garcia	-6.80	384	0.00	-6.80
361	Andrew Toles	-6.98	351	0.00	-6.98
362	Charlie Tilson	-7.14	391	0.00	-7.14
363	Danny Espinosa	-8.02	367	0.00	-8.02
364	David Freese	-8.22	469	0.00	-8.22
365	Wilmer Flores	-8.47	413	0.00	-8.47
366	J.J. Hardy	-8.50	447	0.00	-8.50
367	Michael Conforto	-9.01	323	0.00	-9.01
368	Alex Dickerson	-9.18	395	0.00	-9.18
369	Angel Pagan	-9.57	476	0.00	-9.57
370	Gerardo Parra	-10.25	406	0.00	-10.25
371	Chris Owings	-10.94	301	0.00	-10.94
372	Dan Vogelbach	-10.95	420	0.00	-10.95
373	Melvin Upton	-13.07	362	0.00	-13.07
374	Yoan Moncada	-14.66	245	2.00	-16.66
375	Marwin Gonzalez	-14.96	439	0.00	-14.96
376	Ketel Marte	-15.06	352	0.00	-15.06
377	Raul Mondesi	-15.48	393	0.00	-15.48
378	Aaron Altherr	-15.72	449	0.00	-15.72
379	Mallex Smith	-15.76	355	0.00	-15.76
380	Freddy Galvis	-15.80	360	0.00	-15.80
381	Scooter Gennett	-16.85	461	0.00	-16.85
382	Tyler Saladino	-16.97	422	0.00	-16.97
383	Tony Wolters	-17.77	383	0.00	-17.77
384	David Wright	-18.06	520	0.00	-18.06
385	Delino DeShields	-18.61	517	0.00	-18.61
386	Andrew Susac	-18.63	412	0.00	-18.63
387	Cheslor Cuthbert	-18.90	483	0.00	-18.90
388	Joey Gallo	-19.69	427	0.00	-19.69
389	Tucker Barnhart	-21.17	387	0.00	-21.17
390	Ben Revere	-21.55	345	0.00	-21.55
391	Miguel Montero	-22.27	450	0.00	-22.27
392	A.J. Reed	-24.47	488	0.00	-24.47
393	Bruce Maxwell	-24.51	477	0.00	-24.51
394	Roman Quinn	-24.70	414	0.00	-24.70
395	Jorge Alfaro	-24.79	459	0.00	-24.79
396	Blake Swihart	-25.14	460	0.00	-25.14
397	Jefry Marte	-26.26	436	0.00	-26.26
398	Nick Hundley	-26.53	438	0.00	-26.53
399	Raimel Tapia	-30.22	514	0.00	-30.22
400	Brett Lawrie	-32.21	401	0.00	-32.21

One issue at the very top is I used NFBC auction values to generate the top-21 ADP picks (through Chris Sale), and only afterwards multiplied by ~.998 for each subsequent pick until it reached ~$1 at pick No. 276 (12 teams * 23 players). In other words, the NFBC owner picking first isn't literally spending $44.38 on the pick - that's merely what his auctioning counterparts spent, and I had to use something to generate a baseline. Also, somewhat arbitrarily, I didn't start making each successive ADP slot uniformly lower until Sale (last $30 player). Even so, I think the NFBC "dollar values" do approximate what each slot is worth to them, particularly after Sale and serves as a useful point of comparison.

In the next post, I'll sort by the biggest dollar value outliers and see if there's any edge to be found is seeing where man (NFBC ADP) and machine (Steamer) most strongly disagree.